Involving Procurement when a need is first defined makes it possible to explore alternatives, assess market conditions and prepare a negotiation with viable options. When the department only becomes involved after the supplier has been selected and the purchase is largely agreed, some of that negotiating room has already been lost.
The situation is familiar: a department needs equipment or a service, contacts a supplier, receives a proposal and agrees a date. It then passes the quotation to Procurement to try to improve the price.
Procurement can still add value at that stage. However, it must negotiate around decisions already made, with less time to review other options. This is the situation highlighted by Gestplast in its post on early Procurement involvement.
When the department joins the process affects what it can achieve.
What Changes When Procurement Joins at the End?
A negotiation depends, among other factors, on the alternatives available and the time needed to pursue them.
If the supplier knows it is the preferred choice, the scope has been built around its solution and delivery is urgent, switching may be difficult. Finding another candidate means reviewing requirements, requesting a proposal and checking that it can deliver.
In these circumstances, Procurement usually focuses on the aspects still open to discussion: price, payment terms, warranties or particular services.
The problem arises when its contribution is measured solely by the final discount, without considering which decisions had already been made before it could get involved.
How Strategic Procurement Adds Value from the Start
Exploring Alternative Suppliers and Solutions
The first step is to understand the problem the business needs to solve.
The requester and technical teams understand the intended use, required performance and operational constraints. Procurement can help communicate that need to the market and identify suppliers capable of meeting it.
When information is missing, a request for information allows the team to explore capabilities and solutions before asking for a final quotation. This helps avoid narrowing the process prematurely around the first proposal received.
Assessing Market Prices and Commercial Terms
Receiving several responses helps establish which terms are available and which differences need clarification.
A price may depend on the requested volume, lead time, scope or included services. Procurement can identify these variables and request the necessary clarifications before treating two proposals as comparable.
This assessment provides a reference for negotiation and a basis for explaining the eventual decision.
Preparing an RFQ with Clear Requirements
An RFQ, or request for quotation, allows the company to request prices and terms for a defined requirement.
Preparing it with the requester helps clarify:
- The scope of the goods or services.
- Quantities and units.
- Mandatory technical requirements.
- Delivery dates and conditions.
- The documentation the supplier must provide.
- The items that must be included in the price.
The clearer the request, the easier it becomes to identify exclusions and assess quotations on a consistent basis.
Assessing Costs, Risks, Quality and Service
Price is one part of the decision, alongside other factors that may affect the outcome of the purchase.
A proposal may involve installation, transport or maintenance costs. It may also raise questions about supply capacity, response times or compliance with quality requirements.
Early involvement allows the team to define what needs checking and who will carry out each review. Supplier management helps organise this information, although each purchase requires an assessment of its specific circumstances.
How Procurement and Technical Teams Work Together
Collaboration works best when everyone understands their responsibilities and shares the information needed to make a decision.
| Team or role | Contribution to the process |
|---|---|
| Requester | Explain the need, intended use and required date |
| Technical team | Define and validate performance specifications and mandatory requirements |
| Procurement | Organise market enquiries, compare commercial terms and prepare negotiations |
| Approver | Authorise the decision in line with the company’s criteria and procedures |
The precise allocation will depend on the organisation. In a small company, one person may perform several roles.
What matters is agreeing who validates each aspect and when. If a quotation contains a technical exception, Procurement needs to know whether it is acceptable before using it as an alternative in negotiations.
Example: Buying Equipment with Procurement Involved from the Start
Imagine a company that needs to add a piece of equipment to its production facilities. The following example is fictional and illustrates two ways of organising the process.
When the Quotation Arrives with Most Terms Already Agreed
The requester has chosen a model, spoken to a supplier and needs delivery soon. Procurement receives the proposal to negotiate a reduction.
It can review the terms and request improvements, but introducing another solution would require a new technical assessment. The schedule limits that possibility.
When the Need Is Shared Before a Solution Is Chosen
The requester explains the required capacity, space restrictions and target date. The technical team defines which specifications are essential, and Procurement approaches suppliers that could meet them.
The responses allow the team to review alternatives, clarify what each price includes and identify potential delivery problems. Once the proposals have been validated, the team can negotiate with viable candidates.
The difference lies in the options still available when negotiations begin. Early involvement provides more room to develop them; the actual outcome will depend on the market and the characteristics of the purchase.
How to Involve Procurement Earlier
1. Share the Need Before Committing to a Solution
Procurement should be informed while there is still time to define the scope and explore the market.
This is particularly useful for purchases involving significant expenditure, technical complexity, long lead times or dependence on a supplier.
2. Separate Mandatory Requirements from Preferences
The team should distinguish essential conditions from those that allow alternatives.
This distinction makes it possible to evaluate different proposals without losing sight of the original need. It also helps prevent an unchecked preference from becoming a barrier to other suppliers.
3. Allow Time for Enquiries and Validation
The schedule should allow for preparing the request, supplier responses, clarifications and technical review.
If all this work must take place once the purchase is already urgent, the team will have less opportunity to address an incomplete proposal or assess another option.
4. Enter Negotiations with Viable Quotations
Before negotiating, confirm that candidates can meet the requirements and that any conditions or exceptions have been addressed.
This preparation is especially important when negotiating through an electronic auction. Our guide on what to validate before starting an electronic auction explains the checks covering technical compliance, scope and exclusions.
How to Assess Procurement’s Contribution
A price reduction is a useful indicator when there is a clear reference point. It is also worth assessing what the process contributed before reaching that result.
For example:
- Viable alternatives identified and evaluated.
- Exclusions clarified before contracting.
- Additional costs included in the comparison.
- Delivery commitments confirmed.
- Supply risks identified.
- Selection criteria and reasons documented.
These elements help explain the quality of the decision. A rigorous assessment should rely on recorded information and avoid claiming savings against hypothetical costs that have not been verified.
Prepare the Purchase to Negotiate with More Options
In Gestplast’s procurement consulting work, coordination with the requester and technical teams forms part of process preparation. APTSE provides a digital environment for organising requests, proposals and supplier communications.
APTSE’s RFQ software helps structure the information this collaboration requires. Validation and decisions remain the responsibility of the people managing the purchase.
If you are preparing a purchase, involving Procurement before selecting a supplier allows the team to work on more than the final discount. Contact the APTSE team to discuss your next negotiation.



