Preparing an electronic auction means checking that suppliers can compete against the same purchasing requirements. Before negotiations begin, you need to validate technical compliance, clarify commercial terms and confirm that each proposal is suitable for a potential contract award.
Receiving several quotations is a step forward, but significant differences may remain: one supplier excludes transport, another proposes a later delivery date, and a third offers a technical alternative that has not yet been approved.
As Gestplast explains in its LinkedIn post, these differences should be resolved before moving negotiations into an auction. Preparation helps the buyer understand what each price covers and the conditions attached to it.
From RFQ to Auction: When Are Quotations Ready?
An RFQ, or request for quotation, collects prices and commercial terms for a defined purchasing requirement. Once responses arrive, the procurement team needs to decide which proposals can move forward to negotiation.
It helps to distinguish between three stages:
- Quotation received: the supplier has responded, but the proposal still needs to be reviewed.
- Clarification required: information is missing or differences need to be resolved.
- Validated for negotiation: the necessary checks are complete, and the scope on which the supplier will participate is defined.
This distinction prevents an incomplete proposal from being treated as ready to compete.
Four Checks Before Starting the Auction
1. Validate Technical Compliance
The responsible team should confirm that the proposed solution meets the mandatory requirements.
Depending on the purchase, this review may involve technical specifications, supporting documents, samples, tests or approval from the requesting department. Record what has been checked, who has approved it and which issues remain unresolved.
If a supplier proposes an alternative, assess it before admitting it to the negotiation. The decision may be to accept the alternative, request a revision or reject it because it fails to meet an essential requirement.
A lower price does not, by itself, resolve a technical incompatibility.
2. Align Scope and Commercial Terms
Aligning quotations means establishing a consistent basis for comparison.
The review should establish whether all suppliers are quoting for the same quantities, deliverables and relevant conditions. For example:
- Required units and volumes.
- Included services or work.
- Delivery, transport and installation, where applicable.
- Schedule and supply commitments.
- Required warranties and support.
- Currency, payment terms and quotation validity.
Where differences are accepted, define how they will be assessed. If they substantially change what is being purchased, it may be necessary to compare the alternatives beforehand or negotiate separate scopes.
3. Resolve Exclusions and Exceptions
The qualifications attached to a proposal can change what its price actually represents.
Statements such as “installation excluded”, “lead time subject to availability” or “price conditional on a minimum order” need to be addressed before negotiations begin.
A simple record can help track these issues:
| Issue identified | Required action | Condition for closing the issue |
|---|---|---|
| A requested item is missing | Ask the supplier to include it or clarify how it will be handled | Updated scope and price |
| The proposed delivery date differs from the requirement | Confirm whether the supplier can meet the required schedule | Documented delivery commitment |
| A technical alternative is proposed | Request a review by the responsible team | Recorded acceptance or rejection |
| A commercial condition differs | Assess its impact and agree how it will be handled | Clarified and accepted condition |
Each clarification should be linked to the version of the quotation that will be used in the auction.
If a common requirement changes, all affected participants should receive the same update and have a reasonable opportunity to revise their proposals.
4. Confirm That Participants Are Eligible for Contract Award
Before inviting a supplier, consider this question: if its proposal is selected, could we award it the contract under the agreed conditions?
Answering this requires checking the requirements that apply to the purchase, including any necessary internal approvals and the supplier’s capacity to deliver.
Supplier management provides information to support this assessment. However, a supplier’s qualification for a particular category does not mean that every proposal it submits is suitable for a specific project.
You should also explain how the final decision will be made. Taking part in an auction does not automatically result in a contract award unless the process rules explicitly provide for it.
Example: Four Prices, Different Conditions
Imagine a purchase of industrial equipment. This fictional example illustrates the checks needed before negotiation.
Four suppliers submit proposals:
| Supplier | Quotation status | What to check before negotiation |
|---|---|---|
| A | Includes equipment, transport and installation | Confirm compliance and commercial terms |
| B | Excludes installation | Request a proposal covering the required scope |
| C | Proposes delivery later than required | Establish whether it can meet the schedule |
| D | Proposes an alternative technical solution | Obtain the relevant technical assessment |
At this stage, having four prices does not yet provide a consistent basis for negotiation.
After clarification, some proposals may be validated and others may need to be rejected. The number of participants should reflect the viable alternatives available.
Checklist to Prepare an Electronic Auction
Before configuring the event, the procurement team can review the following points:
- Finalised scope: there is a common, up-to-date version of the purchasing requirement.
- Technical validation: mandatory requirements and proposed alternatives have been assessed and resolved.
- Comparable terms: quantities, delivery arrangements and commercial conditions have a defined treatment.
- Resolved exclusions: no outstanding issues could materially change the price or deliverables.
- Eligible participants: suppliers meet the requirements needed to be considered for contract award.
- Communicated rules: participants understand what is being negotiated and how the outcome will be used.
- Prepared documentation: each participant’s valid quotation is identified, together with the baseline used to measure any improvement.
Where an unresolved point affects the viability of the purchase, it should be addressed before bidding starts.
How Technology Supports This Preparation
A platform can help organise documents, responses and clarifications.
APTSE’s RFQ software enables buyers to structure cost breakdowns, analyse proposals and centralise supplier communications. These capabilities help keep process information organised and accessible.
Decisions about technical compliance, acceptance of exceptions and contract award remain with those responsible for the purchase. The information recorded in the platform supports those decisions and provides a record of them.
With this preparation complete, an electronic auction can take place under conditions understood by participants and assessed by the buyer.
Prepare Your Next Negotiation with APTSE
Before starting an auction, review which quotations are ready to compete and which clarifications remain outstanding.
APTSE provides tools to organise requests for quotation and electronic negotiations. The Gestplast team can also help you prepare and manage the process.
Contact our team to discuss your next purchase or request an APTSE demonstration.



